The famous English publishing firm Batsford (www.chrysalisbooks.com), which first
produced chess books in the late 1960s, is still
going strong. Their three new releases: AN
ATTACKING REPERTOIRE FOR WHITE, THE ENGLISH ATTACK,
and BLACK IS STILL OK! all deal with the opening
stage of the game, but in much different ways.
AN ATTACKING REPERTOIRE FOR WHITE is an excellent book by
the former Irish champion Sam Collins. The
repertoire book idea first came to the public's
attention after the appearance of Keene
and Levy's OPENING REPERTOIRE FOR THE ATTACKIG
PLAYER, back in the 1970s, but the present
volume is much better than O.R.A.P. or any
of the subsequent successors devoted to 1.e4.
One reason for this is that Collins gives the reader a repertoire
that isn't dumbed down. Like the above-mentioned
O.R.A.P., AN ATTACKING REPERTOIRE FOR WHITE recommends
the Panov-Botvinnik Attack against the Caro Kann,
but Collins goes with solid main lines and not Gunderam's
cheesy early c5 advocated by Keene and Levy.
Another is that the suggested lines mesh nicely
together. Collins proposes 2.c3 against the Sicilian
and the Advance variation against the French.
This is a good thing because after 1.e4 c5 2.c3
e6 3.d4 d5 White has only one real try to fight
for an advantage – 4.e5 transposing into
the Advance French.
Unlike the first repertoire book, Weaver Adams' WHITE
TO PLAY AND WIN, Collins makes no such wild
claims, but his suggested lines do pack
some punch. In addition to the Alapin versus
the Sicilian and the Advance against the French he
proposes the Scotch, 4.Bg5 versus the Pirc and
meeting the Alekhine with 4.Nf3. Lesser lines
like the Scandinavian, Petroff and Philidor are
also covered, often in a very thematic, easy
to remember fashion. For example against the
Philidor, Collins likes a Ruy Lopez-style treatment
with Bc4, a4, b3, Bb2, and then Nc3-e2-g3 with
c2-c4 (after Bd3) in the air. The key section
of the book is the Sicilian where he advocates
meeting the main line with 2…Nf6 with
Pavasovic's 3.e5 Nd5 4.d4 cxd4 5.Nf3 Nc6 6.cxd4
d6 7.Bc4 Nb6 8.Bb3!? Theoretically this line
may not be that dangerous but it not so well-known
and has scored well in practical play.
AN ATTACKING REPERTOIRE FOR WHITE is a bit more demanding
than many of the other one volume repertoire
books, but the author is there to help out
with plenty of helpful explanation. The student
that takes up these systems will need to be able
to play open, semi-open and closed middlegames.
In other words this is not the book for 1500
player or someone who doesn't like to study,
but for those 1800 on up, with some ambitions,
this book can help a lot.
Recommended!
THE ENGLISH ATTACK by American Grandmasters Nick deFirmian
and John Fedorowicz is a testament to the vitality
of chess. Capablanca thought chess was played
out in the 1920s and here the two authors have
produced a substantial book of over 250 pages
on an opening line that has only been around
20 years!
The idea of playing f3, Be3 and Qd2 has always been the
fundamental way to meet the Dragon variation
of the Sicilian, but answering the Najdorf, where
the Black Bishop goes to e7, this way took a
while to catch on. Now it is the way to
meet 5...a6 and THE ENGLISH ATTACK is
filled with game references from 2003 and 2004
which attest to its popularity at all levels.
The book is divided into two main parts, those where Black
meets 6.Be3 with 6...e5 (covered by lifetime
Najdorf aficionado deFirmian) and Scheveningen
setups with 6…e6 (handled by Federowicz).
There is a huge amount of material to cover here,
with many transpositional possibilities, but
the authors do an excellent job of organizing
the material and offer the reader plenty of prose
to explain key ideas and strategies. Though this
is a complex system, the authors make the material
accessible to a wide range of players from Expert
(2000) strength on up. Those who play the Najdorf
or meet it with the English Attack must have
this book.
Recommended!
BLACK IS STILL OK! by Hungarian Grandmaster Andras Adorjan
is not your run of the mill book. A former
Candidate for the World Championship, the psychologically
fragile Adorjan is definitely a man who marches
to his own drummer. A former trainer of Kasparov
and Leko (who he taught both the Grunfeld and
Sveshnikov!) his credentials are well respected
in the chess world. Back in the 1980s Adorjan
started writing that the advantage of the first
move was overrated and explained his reasons
for this (psychological factors, emphasis on
preparation for White, lack of a dynamic approach
for Black etc.). He published a book BLACK IS
OK! in 1988. The present, original work, with
contributions from some of his collaborators
and feedback from readers, continues in this
vein.
BLACK IS STILL OK! has lots of philosophical discussion
regarding the value of the first move, it also
offers some hard chess content. The Nimzo-line
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.Qc2 0-0 5.a3 Bxc3+
6.Qxc3 b5!? is covered and serves as a good example
of the sort of dynamic chess that Adorjan is
advocating. There is also an examination of the
Grunfeld Hungarian variation – 5.Qb3 dxc4
6.Qxc4 0-0 7.e4 a6. Adorjan's experiences seconding
Candidate Kevin Spraggett, whom he affectionently(!?)
dubs the Canadian Bastard, make for interesting
if one-sided reading. There are plenty of interesting
stories of Adorjan's experiences with the young
Garry Kasparov. The final chapter, My Thesis
in Practice, shows just how fine and and creative
a player Adorjan was.
This is not a book for everyone. Unlike the two books reviewed
earlier it is not a stand-alone work if you want
to play one of the opening lines advocated. It
is more a potpourri. Still, you will find lots
of original analysis and ideas that will be found
nowhere else. |