I
can't recommend Gufeld's Exploiting
Small Advantages because
I don't think that it's well written or useful
to the average player. There are also a number
of technical problems and poor analyses. Normally
I would just forego comment upon it, but certain
things about the book relate to my objections
in my review of Gufeld's Chess:
The Search for the Mona Lisa.
By all accounts this is a revision of his 1985
(Batsford) work of the same title, with many chapter
titles and quotes in common (I should add that
I do not have a copy of the earlier book). This
fact is not mentioned in the new version, just
as with his "Mona Lisa." Is this just
the publisher's fault? I don't think so; as an
author, I can't imagine omitting the fact that
I was revising an earlier work, nor do I think
that other writers would do so! Such an omission
is (to put it mildly) deceptive. And on a much
more serious note, the question of Gufeld's plagiarism
in this book has been brought up by more than
one reviewer. Writing for Chess
Horizons magazine, one
of the best if not the best state magazines in
the United States, Editor Mark Donlan points out
two examples in which Gufeld blatantly lifts ChessBase
textual commentary by both Daniel King and Alexander
Baburin and inserts it in the book as his own
writing, in one case with only a change of tense
and in the other with a mere rearrangement of
some of the sentences. This should not be acceptable.
Without even having the redeeming factor of good
chess material, I don't think that Exploiting
Small Advantages deserves
your consideration.
YOU
CAN FIND THIS BOOK AT

|