This hefty volume provides truly extensive coverage
of a variation that is the staple of many strong
positional players with the white pieces. Without
a doubt, this is a significant work and must read
for strong players that either play or face these
variations. It is an open question whether it
will have the same appeal to players further down
the rating list.
The author is a strong grandmaster
from the country of Georgia, and he has written
two other openings books for Gambit Publications.
In each case, the books provide exhaustive coverage
of the variations that form its subject matter
(the previous two covered the Petroff and a black
repertoire featuring coverage of the Queen’s
Gambit Declined and Catalan). The theory is catalogued,
and the author provides authoritative readings
on the state of each variation.
While the author’s willingness
to gather and provide judgment on current theory
is clear, this (and his other opening books) are
not as user friendly as many players would like.
While the chapter introductions are helpful and
there are reasonable discussions where there are
major branches within variations, there is no
summary of material at the end of chapters, and
there is little guidance other than final evaluations
at points where theory diverges into sub-subvariations.
The introduction is also brief, and there are
many pages crammed full of game fragments with
just the barest of explanations of ideas or summary
of why one player or another is better.
In the past, I’ve commented
on the fact that there is more than one acceptable
way to write an opening book. While I generally
prefer books with lots of explanation and discussion
of key points, this may detract from the theoretical
coverage. While I would generally prefer the author
provide some original analysis and be prepared
to critically discuss the evaluations of others,
sometimes you have to settle for simply the latter.
This book would definitely fall into that category.
The author provides plenty of assessment, and
the theory is organized to provide an up-to-date
view, but there are not a lot of examples of new
ideas or alternatives that have not already been
mentioned by others.
Some reviewers (and authors) are not quite as
willing to settle for “half a loaf.”
John Watson, for example, is an author and reviewer
who I greatly respect and admire, and his books
are true labors of love that contain an incredible
amount of original analysis and insight. He believes
that this is a requisite part of a truly good
book, and I’m finding it increasingly hard
not to agree – with the ease of use of chess
databases and availability of current games, book
authors need to “add value” to make
their products stand out, and new ideas and analysis
are one way to do so.
This book is probably best suited
to the white player who plays the g3 systems against
either the King’s Indian or Grunfeld. It’s
worth noting that some strong players (such as
John Nunn) believe that the g3 systems take so
much of the dynamism out of the King’s Indian
that black’s best is to transpose into the
Grunfeld with …d5. The book’s coverage
makes this ideal for the white practitioner –
in the past that player had to purchase books
on both the King’s Indian and Grunfeld to
deal with black’s options after, say 1.d4
Nf6 2.c4 g6 3.g3. As an added bonus, the book
covers another early divergence, 3…Bg7 4.Bg2
c5.
Of course, there are black players
who will find the book useful as well. The author
appears neutral in his evaluations, and the book
is written with the “variation tree”
approach (rather than via illustrative games).
As a result, the coverage is deep, and it is also
quite current. There are several lines in this
complex that have seen significant change in evaluations
in the past few years, so a serious King’s
Indian player may find it worth the purchase price.
At the same time, this is not a
white variation that is routinely essayed by players
below about 2200 ELO. While strong white players
can often “soak up” black’s
counterplay and eventually gain a sizable advantage
because of white’s space advantage, this
is not a simple task against active players. As
a consequence, the set-up is probably not the
average black King’s Indian player’s
foremost concern, and they may be able to get
by without this book.
In conclusion, this hefty look at
a sophisticated variation packs a ton of theory
(and game fragments) into its 320 pages. While
it is definitely the latest word on the variations
in question, it is not an easy variation to essay
(for either side!) and the author doesn’t
exactly improve its accessibility for the average
player. While strong players and serious students
of the variation will need this book, others may
be able to muddle through without it.
To see John Donaldson’s review
of this book, click HERE.
YOU
CAN FIND THIS BOOK AT

|