From my
experience, chess is never all that simple, and
books that treat it so are mostly oversimplified,
but there are exceptions. Here, grandmaster Emms
provides interesting discussion – and depth – in
a way that does, indeed, make some advanced positional
concepts more readily understandable.
This is
the follow-up to an earlier work, titled (no
big surprise) SIMPLE CHESS. I confess I did not
look at the first volume – I readily admit to
a bias against books with the word “simple” in
their title. Too often this seems to be a tacit
signal that the author has dumbed down the content
to appeal to those wishing everything to be,
well, simple. I'm glad I took the opportunity
to delve a little deeper into this volume.
The author
has chosen topics that often confound the player
seeking to improve their positional play. These
include dealing with problem pieces (improving
your worst placed piece, inducing an opponent
to put a piece on a less desirable square, and
taking advantage of an out of play piece); fighting
with and against the bishop pair; and utilizing
kings, queens, and rooks. The book benefits from
the use of a lot of examples where matters are
not as clear cut as are often found in instructional
manuals. As Emms notes in the introduction, it's
a lot less interesting when most readers can
figure out what should (or shouldn't) be done
in a particular position. In that respect, he
succeeds – I found many positions where the solution
surprised and interested me. In the end, that
is how one advances their chess learning.
Perhaps
the book's longest chapter, on issues dealing
with trades, is also its best. Emms spends 41
pages on the topic, and it is time well spent.
The author notes that discussions of exchanges
are not often found in chess literature (as he
notes, GM Peter Wells suggests that editors prefer
the word ‘sacrifice' to ‘exchange'). Here he
covers exchanging to remove an attacker, a defender,
a worst placed piece, exchanging to open lines,
to inflict weaknesses, to control a color complex,
etc. Of course, the yang to the “exchange is
good” yin is that in many cases one should refrain
from exchanging, and Emms covers these as well.
All through, there is instructive discussion – I
particularly enjoyed the Balashov quote that “Fischer
almost never has any bad pieces. He exchanges
them, and the bad pieces remain with his opponents.” This
is the sort of practical insight that can prove
valuable to the reader.
I can see
how a thorough study of this overlooked topic
could bring big benefits to many players. One
of my chess “epiphanies” came by way of Mednis'
FROM THE MIDDLEGAME INTO THE ENDGAME, where he
explained that often the defending queen was
the glue that held the defender's position together.
I would guess I've won at least a dozen tournament
games from learning this important concept. There
are several in Emms' book that could prove similarly
rewarding.
Besides
the content, each chapter contains exercises
to cover the concepts, with the answers found
at the back of the book. The solutions themselves
often contain paragraphs of additional insight
that should benefit the reader.
The author
himself addresses the question of whether this
is a sequel that demands knowledge of the original
book, and I tend to agree that this can function
as a stand-alone work. My guess is that the original
book was a bit more basic, and this is largely
addressing topics that reach beyond the first
book. As a way of bridging any coverage gap concerns,
the introduction gives a brief synopsis of the
key lessons from SIMPLE CHESS.
My only
real question about this book relates to coverage
and the all-important price to pages ratio. I
found the content here enjoyable, but I couldn't
help but wonder whether the reader would have
been better served by combining the books and,
perhaps improving the price to page ratio a bit.
This, of course, is something that each individual
reader will have to judge for himself. Those
who are particularly price conscious should probably
deduct a half point from my rating.
In the end, though, John Emms is an excellent chess
author who presents interesting material. He covers
important topics in a way that doesn't shortchange
his readers. Here he covers many slightly advanced
positional topics in a way that should make them
more accessible to the average player.