When I review a film, there are certain laws
of nature you can count on. If it's got wirework,
I won't like it. If it's very plotty - and HERO'S
got multiple plot lines - I won't like it. If
it's got Jet Li, I won't like it. If it's completely
devoid of humor, I ain't gonna like it. Well.
HERO has all of these things, and it's easily
the best martial arts film I've seen all year.
I hate to recite plots, so once again, from
the DVD case:
"At the end of China's Warring States, the
Kingdom of Qin is the most ruthless and ambitious
of the seven states. Its King is the target
of assassins from all over China. Of all the
would-be assassins, Broken Sword, Flying Snow
and Sky are the most dangerous. When Nameless
kills all three, he is offered a chance to meet
the King. Nameless explains to the King how
he used their personal relationships to expose
and attack their weaknesses, but the King tells
a different version of the same story."
The plot summary alone kept me from popping
this disc into the player for weeks. As I said,
I'm not a plotty person. Don't let it scare
you, and that's all I'll say before I give something
away.
Visually, HERO really is like nothing I've
ever seen before. There are color schemes for
each major chapter in the story. The extras
on Disc Two of this set describe them as red
for "passion," blue for "romance," and white
for "truth." The costumes, landscapes, and elaborate
sets all change with the story. This excruciating
attention to detail allows the viewer to fully
enter the fantasy - and enables curmudgeons
like me to accept the wirework.
Yes, let's talk about those fight scenes. I
complain quite frequently and loudly about wirework,
CGI, and fast editing. In general, I like to
see real people moving the way real people can
- on the ground! Needless to say, I wasn't a
huge fan of CROUCHING TIGER, HIDDEN DRAGON.
But where that film's fight scenes differ from
HERO's is in the tempo. CROUCHING TIGER is like
speed metal, and maybe I'm just getting too
old for speed metal. HERO goes the other way.
Everything is in slow motion. And it's beautiful.
Some of you may ask, "What about the forest
scene in CROUCHING TIGER? That's in slo-mo."
And I don't have a clear explanation. Again,
maybe it's the attention to detail. Or perhaps
we get to see Jet Li and Donnie Yen in slo-mo
- two guys who move a wee bit better than Chow
Yun Fat.
Presenting everything in slo-mo means that
everything flows. And I mean everything.
Robes, hair, sand, drapes, leaves. The sets
have a life of their own, and the overall effect
is so convincing, that even I had to
forgive, and actually enjoy, the wirework. Kudos
to cinematographer Christopher Doyle. Fucking
brilliant.
Of course, all of this art direction and fight
choreography means nothing if the actors aren't
up to snuff. Well, the acting is top notch all
around. Why is it that when a bunch of marquee
names in Hollywood star in the same film, it
sucks? Yet here we have some of the biggest
names in Chinese film, and the result really
is epic - one of the most overused words in
film reviews - but in this case, it does fit
the bill. Chen Daoming is exactly how
I would imagine an emperor. Maggie Cheung, Donnie
Yen, Zhang Ziyi, and my fave, Tony Leung Chiu
Wai - all subtly brilliant and proving that
less really is more. And, yes, I even liked
Jet Li this time around.
Earlier I mentioned the lack of humor. It's
torturous to watch a film that takes itself
too seriously or is painfully self-important.
HERO is so good, though, it pulls off this sweeping
story, raising questions about politics, martyrdom,
and, of course, love. At a time when cynicism
and irony are revered, HERO, without a shred
of humor, is a welcome change. As Morrissey
once wailed, "It's so easy to laugh. It's so
easy to hate. It takes guts to be gentle
and kind." HERO's got guts.
One final note. Some of you may already be
aware of Miramax/Disney's intentions to release
a hacked-to-pieces, dumbed down, fucked up version
of HERO in the United States. Don't let this
happen! Call Disney at 1-800-72-DISNEY or email
them at disneyinfo@disneyhelp.com.
Uh, but please don't use the language that I
have here. Let's state our case politely and
intelligently.
Click to see reviews of this film by Val Frost
and Silman.