Earlier today Frosty and I bicycled to the Mayan
for a matinee. The theme of Jill Sprecher's pretentious
13 CONVERSATIONS ABOUT ONE THING is that we don't
know whether we'll be happy or unhappy in the
future. If you don't already know this, I urge
you to see the film; otherwise, you might be better
off catching SCOOBY-DOO or DIVINE SECRETS OF THE
YA-YA SISTERHOOD.
Each of the thirteen
episodes is contrived in an embarrassingly obvious
and heavy-handed way to teach us that the vicissitudes
of fortune are unpredictable, an idea that Sprecher
treats with reverent seriousness, as though it
were some intricate and profound truth revealed
to her in a mystical vision. Sprecher studied
philosophy and literature in college, and what
she learned there is reflected in the dialogue,
which is sophomoric, stilted, pseudo-intellectual,
and hackneyed. The actors do the best they can;
Alan Arkin in particular struggles heroically
to make his platitudinous, overblown speeches
sound like real talk, but it's an impossible task.
Sprecher alternates
the conversations with meaningless drawn-out shots
of the characters driving, walking up stairs,
standing in front of doors, sitting in chairs,
and hanging their heads over glassfuls of Scotch
on the rocks. The same sappy mood music floods
the soundtrack again and again in a futile attempt
to keep these prolonged shots from seeming to
be the dead spots they actually are. The music
also overlays some of the conversations, muting
them and making it difficult to hear the words,
an effect I found pleasing considering the artificiality
of the dialogue.
There's one aspect
of CONVERSATIONS for which Sprecher does deserve
some sort of praise or special award: she's succeeded
in creating the most completely unbelievable cleaning
ladies I've ever seen in a movie. Don't blame
Clea Duvall and Tia Texada; the fault lies entirely
in the clothing they were required to wear, the
"cleaning equipment" they were required
to carry around with them, and the lines they
were required to deliver with a straight face.
At first I was going
to give this flick a zero, but then I realized
that it's actually a wee bit better than THE ROYAL
TENENBAUMS, the film by which a Watson rating
of 1 is defined, so to be fair I must grudgingly
admit that 13 CONVERSATIONS ABOUT ONE THING deserves
a rating of 1.3 -- one tenth of a point for each
episode.
My rating on the Watson
scale: 1.3

|