|
Clouzot's classic suspense thriller WAGES OF
FEAR has an interesting history. It won the Grand
Prize at the 1953 Cannes Film Festival, with the
best actor award going to Charles Vanel, and the
British Film Academy named it the best film of
1954. But it wasn't released in the USA until
1955, and then only after the American distributors
had removed nearly all of the scenes in which
Clouzot denounces American oil companies for exploiting,
oppressing, and endangering non-union workers
in Latin America. When my father took my brother
and me to see it, he warned us that people infected
with the witch-hunt mentality of McCarthyism had
gutted the film's political message, and he encouraged
us to imagine the excised scenes so we could fully
appreciate Clouzot's intent.
I was only 13 at the time, but it was easy enough
to do what the old man had suggested, and I was
so impressed by what I saw (and imagined) that
for a year or two WAGES OF FEAR was my favorite
film. In 1991 Criterion finally released the original
148-minute version of the film with all of the
excised scenes restored. Frosty and I watched
it a few days ago, and I was surprised to discover
that while the restored scenes make their point
clearly and strongly, they are not nearly as virulent
and anti-American in their condemnation of the
oil industry as I had imagined them to be.
The story takes place in and around Las Piedras,
an isolated village in an unspecified South American
country. The natives, dressed in rags, impoverished,
diseased, and crippled, watch listlessly as American
representatives of the Southern Oil Company, puffed
up with an inflated sense of self-importance,
tool busily around in their jeeps, splashing mud
in all directions. But the village is also populated
by a polyglot assortment of unemployed European
drifters who sit around all day, better dressed
than the natives but every bit as listless, sipping
lemonade, fanning the flies away, and bitterly
lamenting the fact that they're trapped in a pestilential
hellhole with no way of scraping together enough
money to buy a ticket to the coast. Four of these
ne'er-do-wells, the Corsican Mario (Yves Montand),
the Parisian Jo (Charles Vanel), the German Bimba
(Peter Van Eyck), and the Italian Luigi (Folco
Lulli), are given a chance to escape. All they
have to do is drive two big trucks full of nitroglycerin
over 300 miles of mountainous terrain on a badly
rutted, rock-strewn dirt road, after which the
Southern Oil Company will reward them handsomely
by paying each of them two thousand dollars.
The first half of WAGES OF FEAR, the part that
takes place in the village before the truck journey
begins, is flawed by the inclusion of a character
named Linda (Vera Clouzot). Linda looks weirdly
out of place in Las Piedras. She's nothing more
than a decorative ornament inserted to provide
a pretty face, some cleavage shots, and the semblance
of a romance with Mario. (In this regard, WAGES
OF FEAR reminds me of the Werner Herzog film FITZCARRALDO,
also set in South America. The producers insisted
that Herzog create a role for Claudia Cardinale
so that Klaus Kinski's character would have a
girlfriend. But Kinski's character is a madman
whose only passion is for opera. Cardinale tags
along, valiantly trying to provide "love
interest," but she's obviously an extraneous
afterthought, and the movie would have been much
stronger without her.)
The presence of Linda is not the only flaw in
the first half of WAGES OF FEAR. Many of the secondary
characters have that "colorful" quality
that was de rigueur in Hollywood at the time,
and some of the interactions between the main
characters are also much too Hollywoodish. For
example, there is a confrontation between Jo and
Luigi in a bar. Luigi threatens to whack Jo over
the head with a bottle, but Jo pulls a gun, and
Luigi backs down. To prove that he is a brave
man and Luigi a coward, Jo then hands the gun
to Luigi and dares Luigi to shoot him with it.
This little routine is pure cliché. It
serves an important purpose in the development
of the characters, but that purpose could have
been and should have been accomplished in other,
more realistic ways.
The second half of WAGES OF FEAR is a masterpiece
of nail-biting suspense and unexpected character
revelation. Clouzot achieves an exquisitely nerve-wracking
level of tension in three extended scenes during
the truck journey. Audiences and critics raved
about these scenes when the film was first released.
All three scenes have been copied numerous times
in subsequent movies, but they still retain their
archetypal power when seen today, 50 years later.
Even better than the suspense itself is the revelation
of what happens to Mario, Jo,Bimba, and Luigi
when they're trapped inside the pressure cooker
of fear. We gain an impression of each man in
the first half of the film, then see in the second
half that the truth about each man – the
deep truth – is just the opposite of what
we thought. Clouzot's study of courage and cowardice
is charged with cynicism and irony. Conventional
wisdom tells us that bravery is an attribute found
only in those who are paragons of wisdom and virtue,
but Clouzot insists that men who are stupid and
villainous can sometimes be very brave indeed,
and that bravery for the wrong cause is absurd
and pointless, not heroic.
WAGES OF FEAR has many complementary strengths.
The dramatic musical score by Georges Auric adds
greatly to our growing sense of foreboding. Cinematographer
Armand Thirard makes excellent use of light and
shadow to create a dark, doom-drenched, film-noir
atmosphere. The acting during the truck journey
is highly realistic, both gripping and convincing,
with especially fine performances by Vanel and
Montand. (Prior to this film, Montand was a popular
music hall singer, not an actor. Everyone was
surprised by the high quality of his acting, and
the positive response launched him on a new career.)
And Clouzot makes masterful use of visual metaphors
to underscore the movie's themes. The first shot
in the film is a close-up of four or five large,
cumbersome beetles. Each beetle has a bit of string
knotted around its thorax, and the other ends
of the string are tied to each other. The beetles
crawl through the dirt in different directions,
but they can't escape from the net that holds
them loosely together. The camera pulls back.
We see a half-naked little native boy crouched
over the network of bound beetles. He's using
a stick to lift the beetles and flip them around.
He dangles them, tangling the bits of string,
then drops them back on the ground. Suddenly he
hears the singsong voice of a vendor pushing a
wooden cart with bells on it. The boy discards
the beetles and walks away to check out the vendor.
The camera moves on, showing us the squalor and
filth of Las Piedras, and we quickly forget about
the beetles, just as the little boy himself has
quickly forgotten about them. It is only later,
after the movie is over, that we will (perhaps)
remember this opening moment and understand its
symbolism. Big oil companies treat non-union workers
in undeveloped countries in exactly the same way
that little boys treat insects.
|